Regular price: £29.79
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for £29.79
Listened to the audio book as my chosen format and maybe the long length referred in negative reviews makes the case for listening. Though many of us will never know much at all about our ancestors so brutally killed, Daniel's sharing of his journey brings the truth to us in painful and funny and in educational mixtures so we, too, will feel closer in spirit to family never to be known but always loved. Thanks, Daniel
1 of 1 people found this review helpful
This is an engrossing account of Mr Mendelson's search for lost relatives in the holocaust. It is hard to critic because of the subject matter which at times is truly horrific as would be expected. There are also moments of levity in his wonderful descriptions of elderly Jewish ladies he befriends and help him with his search. One elderly lady in New York who continuely reminds him that his brother is much better looking. However, the digressions into the Torah and Greek tragedy don't really add much to the story and make it rather long winded. There are so many characters and false leads, that is enough to keep up with, the digressions are not needed. It is an incredible story and shows the persistence and endurance that have made an epic, educational and moving read.
This book from a man, a scholar and Classicist, who has spent his life looking back, who travels the world to find the stories of his uncle, aunt, wife and four daughters, reads like a memoir, a detective story, a moral fable, even a romance. It is well-paced and engaging to the point that I put my life on hold just to keep finding out: And then what?
Everyone becomes a fully fleshed-out person: the lost; the old man in Poland who remembers, "The whole town was talking about it; the bodies were there the next day;" the woman in Australia who remembers it all but will die if she has to talk on record; all the way to Mendelsohn himself whose memories range from the childlike to the full-blown, in-your-face.
There are what seem to be digressions for stories from the Torah, from history, from Greek tragedies, but all come to a point. The summations are so beautiful, and the relevance so pointed that they are beyond moving. Simply stunning. Simply lovely.
And Pinchot gives voice to it all, the love, the frustration and anguish, the chuckles and joy. No, really, I mean it. This is the most dramatic, most perfectly nuanced performance I've comes across all year. And trust me, I'm an audio-fanatic. I listen to books like it's the air I breathe.
Brilliant book. The re-imagining of what happened to 16 year old Ruchele will make you cry.
And you'll be grateful to bring her to life for at least that moment. Because despite the horror, at least she was breathing.
She was alive.
10 of 13 people found this review helpful
I wanna see the pictures!!! how do I do that when the book is Audible?