Regular price: £19.69
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for £19.69
Well, this is listed as illustrating 'some brilliant detective work' .... well the judge seems to be ruled by what he 'felt' about the particular accused - no logical evidence shown - in fact it was so 'naff' that I almost enjoyed it! He was guided to his judgements by an explicit dream - which had to be explained to him by his sergeant.
One REALLY irritating point though - the narrator would insist on talking about the 'constipals' rather that 'constables' and I found this really annoying.
I bought this as part of an offer - thank goodness I didn't go to town using up my valuable credits. I really wouldn't recommend this to anyone!
4 of 7 people found this review helpful
If you could sum up Celebrated Cases of Judge Dee (Dee Goong An) in three words, what would they be?
Cross-Cultural, Complicated, Clever-- add Chinese!
Did the plot keep you on the edge of your seat? How?
The judge switched from case to case and they all seemed unrelated and insoluble, but in the end, although the crimes occurred over great distances at times, they seemed to all fit together into an intricate pattern. And the Chinese practically invented paranormal mysteries! They are full of dreams and ghosts and visions of the afterlife. The most wonderful thing about these books though is not just that the stories are great mysteries, the atmosphere is evoked so well and the characters so memorable, but that it is based on a real historical person and the real ancient Chinese entertainment form of detective stories. The explanation of how these stories are converted to suit Western tastes is fascinating. I read these books in paper before taking a Chinese History class and found that the information on ancient Chinese culture contained in the stories was great preparation for the class.
Which character – as performed by the narrators – was your favorite?
I liked the old guard who showed Judge Dee and his other officers to Turnip Pass.
Was there a moment in the book that particularly moved you?
I found it very moving that the rule at the time--which Judge Dee was prepared to follow--was that if a prisoner was tortured and turned out to be innocent, the judge and his officers were to be executed in the prisoner's place. I imagine corruption of justice occurred anyway among lesser officials but if you followed the rules, you would be very careful. I wish today's justice were as scrupulous.
Any additional comments?
I want more Judge Dee audio books on audio please. Their cross cultural background and atmosphere is even better than the stories themselves and is the sort of thing that narration immerses you in even more completely than the written word.
6 of 6 people found this review helpful
A fascinating look inside a legal system much older than our own. Two jarring notes to modern listeners, the use of torture in court, and Judge Dee's reliance on supernatural influences to move a case forward, were nevertheless parts of an administration of justice that lasted more than a thousand years. The performers did a good job all around, and I wish there were more Judge Dee books on Audible.
2 of 2 people found this review helpful