Regular price: £19.09
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for £19.09
How amazing to think of Mark Twain, arch-skeptic and misanthrope, being so taken with the Maid of Orleans. He plays this one straight: there is occasional humor, mostly centered around village life in Donremy or the childhood companions of Joan who join her later as part of her "staff." But Joan herself is taken exactly as she presented herself and as she apparently thought of herself - certainly as many people thought of her in her lifetime: a deeply religious, courageous, and patriotic young woman who wrought a military miracle. There is not the slightest trace of irony in Twain's portrait of her. (If you want a contrast, read Shakespeare's "Henry VI Part One," where Joan figures as a witch, a sadist, and a trull.)
Much of what he says in the book (where he credits himself somewhat archly as a "translator" of the memoirs of one of Joan's aides) is taken, Twain assures us, directly from the historical record. Joan is unique in medieval history in having testimony preserved that was given in two ecclesiastical proceedings: one that condemned her to death, one that posthumously found her innocent. Her own words, her own brilliant responses to many of the questions put to her by inquisitors, are there in the record. So is testimony from people who knew her as a child and as a young woman, as a peasant girl and a warrior. I've read some discussions of the book that suggest Joan was modeled on Twain's daughter Suzy, who died the year the book was published. Maybe so; but if Joan's dialogue in the trial scene is really taken straight from the record, there doesn't seem to be much Twain needed to add.
I'd avoided this novel for a long time, and only read it recently because I'm trying to work my way through all of Twain. I wish I'd done it sooner. It's not his greatest novel, but it's a good one, much better than I'd been led to expect by the many dismissive comments about it I've read over the years. Joan herself is a charming and tragic (and totally credible) figure throughout the book, and the story of her military campaigns and the trial that ended her life are given in richly anchored historical detail. I've since started reading some of the many nonfiction books about Joan: I think I've been bitten.
Robin Field's narration is excellent. He's one of several first-rate narrators of Twain (others include Grover Gardner, Bronson Pinchot, Richard Henzel, and Patrick Fraley). He provides a slight French accent for the novel's narrator, which I don't think was necessary but didn't mind. After Joan's death, I found myself in a somber, thoughtful mood for several hours.
17 of 17 people found this review helpful
Mark Twain had a fascination with Joan of Arc and said this was the best novel he ever wrote. Sharing in Twain's fascination, I have to agree with him. You won't find much of Twain's familiar humor, but you will find faith, patriotism, and heroism on a scale that can't help but inspire. Regardless of your own personal views of Joan of Arc, Twain's writing will either make you believe or at least allow you to suspend your disbelief. It's a well-researched story, and some of his conclusions, while controversial in his day, have turned out to be more true than he knew. I would rank this right up there with Margaret George's The Autobiography of Henry VIII.
The narrator takes a little getting used to. It's clearly a badly faked French accent for the character telling the story, and the feminine version he uses for Joan is even worse. It's almost something out of Monty Python. That said, Robin Field does play it straight, and once you get used to the vocals, the power of the story will pull you in. We all know how it ends, but if you're not moved by how well it's told, you have a hard heart indeed.
2 of 2 people found this review helpful