Regular price: £24.19
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for £24.19
Any additional comments?
Through some error of transcription or typography, sections of many of the stories in this collection have been omitted -- specifically, any and every block quotation (including all poetry) is entirely skipped, and certain paragraphs are inexplicably absent (such as Roderick Usher's climactic dialogue in "The Fall of the House of Usher"). Reviews on the Kindle edition reveal that this is the case there as well, so perhaps the narrator was reading from that version.
In general this narrator is acceptable; he regularly mispronounces certain words, but his evident understanding of Poe's often complex sentence structure makes his reading adequate. I do rather wonder how he could have failed to notice and inquire about the omissions from the text, however, as the passages in question blatantly don't make sense without the missing portions.
Some of the stories don't suffer terribly from this problem, so this collection is still a viable option for anyone seeking audio recordings of Poe's works, but be aware of this bizarre deficiency (which affected most, in my opinion, "The Fall of the House of Usher" and "The Assignation") when purchasing this audiobook.
2 of 2 people found this review helpful
I have no aversion to old prose or pre-modern style, but Poe is about as interesting a being kept alive on life support. I like an author who takes their time, good things and ideas are hard to develop, but Poe takes a life age to advance the story even a hair. He is all form, very little substance. Some people are inclined toward that, and for them maybe this could be excellent listening, but for me, and especially in an audio format, it’s tedious. I care more about the ideas and thoughts being conveyed.