- A Sherlock Holmes and Lucy James Mystery
- Narrated by: Laurence Bouvard, Edward Petherbridge
- Series: The Sherlock Holmes and Lucy James Mysteries, Book 3
- Length: 8 hrs and 12 mins
- Unabridged Audiobook
- Release date: 21-04-17
- Language: English
- Publisher: Charles Veley
- Whispersync for Voice-ready
Regular price: £19.39
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for £19.39
Customer ReviewsMost Helpful
By Mad Margaret on 31-01-18
Not as good as I hoped
What did you like best about Remember, Remember? What did you like least?
I really looked forward to this book, particularly as I had so enjoyed the previous two. However, the writing of this story was not at all up to the same standard and seemed to lack maturity. Sloppy repeated metaphors (I got really tired of hearing about icy grips on her heart or spine) and Americanisms (no Upper Class English woman would know what a "stoop" was, let alone tell her servant to clean it) did not help. The character of Lucy James and her language was all too modern, and distanced the entire novel away from the original Conan Doyle - which I felt the previous two books had captured very well. The idea of Lucy asking Sherlock Holmes for advice on love was excruciating though and that should never have made the cut. I did, however, enjoy the basic plot, even if was now Sherlock-Lite.
How would you have changed the story to make it more enjoyable?
It would need tighter writing.
What didn’t you like about Edward Petherbridge and Laurence Bouvard ’s performance?
Edward Petherbridge was as excellent as ever, although sometimes it did seem as though he had recorded it separately to Laurence Bouvard. I cannot say the same for Laurence Bouvard. As an American, she came across well, but the same cannot be said for her accents, which at times had me laughing out loud. I do understand that the cockney accent is not an easy one for some Americans, but surely someone could have helped her get the crucial vowel sounds right?
If this book were a film would you go see it?
Yes, I might, but the script would need to be much tighter and go back to the original two novels in style. The story itself was rather fun and with the right actors playing the roles it would make a good film.
Any additional comments?
Overall, this book had such a lot of potential, but it was a disappointment when compared to the previous two novels. Perhaps if I had not listened to it as an audio book I would not have felt quite so strongly.
1 of 1 people found this review helpful
Customer ReviewsMost Helpful
By Marily14 on 14-01-18
Ii takes a Sherlock to be a sherlock!
Anywriting that keeps adding to the tales of Sherlock
Holmes I will try! This was an enjoyable addition to the mistyque. The writing is very close to the rhythm of the primary stories. The readers are very good although this Sherlock appears to whisper which I don't enjoy as much. I am heading for the next book in the series. Hopefully it is similarity as good.
2 of 2 people found this review helpful