Regular price: £12.99
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for £12.99
What made the experience of listening to SS-GB the most enjoyable?
James Lailey's reading. I also have his reading of The Ipcress File by the same author and he did such a good job with that so I felt sure he would do a good job with this one too. He did but this book gave him less scope as the characterisation is weaker and gave him less scope for the sardonic humour that he was able to bring to Ipcress.
What was one of the most memorable moments of SS-GB?
The earlier sections were stronger as they were more atmospheric and Deighton did a very good job of recreating the mood of London under Nazi rule. It then rather tailed off as the lack of characterisation became more obvious as the book went on. It also became too embroiled with so much in-fighting between the various Nazi and resistance factions and police man just trying to do his job that I stopped trying to work out where we were and who was fighting against whom.
What does James Lailey bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you had only read the book?
He has a lovely voice and gives distinct characterisation. His women's voices are just right and he did a good job with the accents.
Was there a moment in the book that particularly moved you?
I did find the ending unepxectedly moving but it was rather spoilt by being rather rushed. Deighton spent a lot of time setting up the various factions and then seemed suddenly to remember that the opening scene had involved a murder and the solution to that seemed rather tacked on.
Any additional comments?
This was, I believe, one of the earliest 'what if Hitler had won the war' novels. I had been curious about it for some time, I am glad to gave read it and I think it is worth my four stars. However, it has to be said that other writers have since improved on the genre by keeping it simpler. Robert Harris's Fatherland has some similarities (although it is set in Germany) and is much more involving. The main protagonist in SSGB is not terribly interesting or endearing and the obligatory love interest is not engaging. The machinations of the various factions are over-complicated and overwhelm any real human interest in the characters.
3 of 3 people found this review helpful
Would you consider the audio edition of SS-GB to be better than the print version?
no - but just as enjoyable
What other book might you compare SS-GB to, and why?
fatherland - similar concept w and well researched
Have you listened to any of James Lailey’s other performances? How does this one compare?
Did you have an emotional reaction to this book? Did it make you laugh or cry?
it was very disturbing and thought provoking
Any additional comments?
a well considered and well written book
2 of 2 people found this review helpful