Works well for audio.

This is extremely well narrated. Areas of less well known 19th century social history beautifully brought to life by Sarah Moss and Meriel Schofield.
I removed one star because it dragged towards the end. I found the first half completely captivating.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Well told story of female emancipation and family relationships in a different time 1870s England

The character building , the diverse personality types , how they lived and coped well or badly in that time , the inclusion of art and artists , the descriptions of art , decor , dress and food , the medical context , the engineering context - a well researched and carefully woven tapestry of a story

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

The early days of female doctors.

This was an interesting, if not exactly gripping, account of a middle class family in Manchester during Victorian times, times when women were not expected to want more than a husband, house and children.

Like her mother before her, Elizabeth Sanderson is dedicated to helping the impoverished and downtrodden of Manchester. Her marriage to Alfred Moberley appears to be a marriage of convenience that allows her to continue her good-works. Alfred is an artist and interior designer who designs wallpaper and fabrics for wealthy home owners and although his business is doing well, Elizabeth's upbringing does not allow her to employ servants to do the work she feels she should do herself. When Alethea (Ally) is born Elizabeth is totally out of her depth and has no idea how to care for this squalling baby, so she puts her out of earshot. This neglect continues throughout Ally's life and as a result, she is always striving to impress her mother, or even to be noticed.

She is a studious, conscientious child, in an era when girls did not receive much in the way of education, but she is driven to study and eventually to become a doctor, determined to finally make an impression on her mother. Her sister, May seems less affected by their mother's behaviour and much less serious. She is motivated by the more frivolous side of life.

I was fascinated by the mention of the the Contagious Diseases Act of 1864, which allowed police to detain and inspect any woman walking alone, on suspicion of prostitution. Under the pretext of reducing sexually transferred diseases, women could be subjected to invasive testing on little evidence and it became hazardous to leave the home without a male escort.
This Act was one of the motivations for Elizabeth to press Ally into the medical profession. She felt that women should receive attention from sympathetic female doctors rather than uncaring male ones.It was a very difficult time to become a female doctor, though doors were finally beginning to open. Male colleagues tended to be skeptical and scathing of their female counterparts.

During this time, Ally stayed with her less zealous aunt and realised how different other families were from her own. She also developed a close friendship with another student and finally found a guy who she could relate to.
The story continues with Signs for Lost Children, which follows Ally's work in a mental institution and her husband's time as an engineer in Japan.

I listened to the audio version, well read by Meriel Scholfield, but one problem of this medium was that the introductory descriptions of artworks and their provenances at the beginning of each chapter didn't really work in an audiobook and they became a bit irritating.
3.5 stars.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

9 people found this helpful

loved it

Wonderful story, beautifully researched and written. Such an interesting take on the fight of women to enter university and the professions. The narration is superb. Really enjoyed it.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Great story, well narrated

I adore Sarah Moss’s books and the narration really brought this one to life - loved it.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

No light here

Oh my goodness, I listened to the 5 minute sample and thought it sounds great.

Now one hour in, I am thinking to myself that watching paint dry is an exciting pastime.

I will have to return this, It is a shame it was not a paperback as I could have put it on the fire to keep warm.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful