Regular price: £26.99
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for £26.99
If you’ve listened to books by Jonathan Franzen before, how does this one compare?
I hadn't read any Franzen before. The interview at the end of the audio book was a love-in for white American middle aged men. They avoided talking about all the sex which took up about 50% of the story.
What does the narrators bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you had only read the book?
The male and female readers brought out the gender and age differences well.
What reaction did this book spark in you? Anger, sadness, disappointment?
I got caught up in this book, but then found myself bored and irritated. The sex went on and on, and was written from a very male perspective. The character of Andreas Wolf was not believable whether he was having sex or masturbating - which he did frequently. Annabel was much more believable in terms of her self-obsession, and the conversations between her and Tom as she drew him into her world were masterly and disturbing. Her extreme position on the world, renouncing all her wealth, was much less believable, and her return to her expensive tastes towards the end of the book were unconvincing. Pip was more interestingly conflicted and unsure of herself, with a believable adolescent idealism to begin with. Endearing until Franzen had to fantasise about Wolf and she having sex and then she became a cardboard cut out - he really doesn't do women and sex well, except perhaps as pornography for middle aged men reliving their imaginary youth. There was an attempt to give Pip a happy ending which was trite, first she tries to get them to be reconciled, and then her parents pick up their arguments as if the 20+ years of separation had never happened.
Any additional comments?
Well I did finish it, although the long drawn out story palled eventually. If I'd been reading a print version, probably I would not have. I am not a techie, but I don't think Franzen is either, the technical details were patchy, and the part of the plot about the Sunlight Project exposing secrets was poorly supported with convincing detail. Perhaps prolific and successful male American writers don't need to do research, even when they could afford to employ a researcher.. Would I recommend this book? Well that depends on your taste in pornography, and your gender probably. Up to you!
6 of 6 people found this review helpful
I loved the two previous Franzen books and looked forward to this. However, right now I am struggling to put into words my feelings about this book. It is enough for me that I had to keep making myself listen - it felt like hard work rather than a pleasure to continue. I didn't like any of the characters, they were all annoying or loathsome or both. None of their characterisations rang true to me - they all seemed contrived to the point of being incredible. Much has been said of Franzen's inability to write women but the men were no more or less credible here.
The narrators were all fine except for the ridiculous way the Germans, when speaking German to one another, spoke in 'Cherman' accents.
There was of course some lovely writing (and some not-so lovely writing - what, no editors?) and a couple of laughs but overall, a struggle for this listener..
9 of 10 people found this review helpful
They say that the difficult is not getting there, but "remaining" there.
I have also to admit that I loved Freedom so much that it's really difficult now for me not to read a new book without being a bit "biased"