Regular price: £27.49
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for £27.49
Not wishing to minimize the senseless atrocities perpetrated by ISIS, but they are amateurs compared to the Nazis. Winik, with unrestrained detail chronicles the years of moral depravity of the German and Nazi people toward all who did not fit their definition of correctness. What lessons can we learn from history in closing our response to the evils of genocide? The US has and is guilty. Winik, without specifically proclaiming it, would call a halt to isolation from our moral responsibility to the value of human life. Winik's seamless weaving of so many threads of our recent history into a cohesive, illuminated picture is revelatory. I am so much better informed than I was even having personally lived through the entire epoch. Born in 1930 I was too involved in personal naval gazing to ever perceiving of a personal responsibility to be involved in attempting to effect change--for which I repent. Read the book and ask what your response should be--you may be surprised.
3 of 3 people found this review helpful
I believe that Jay Winik is attempting to claim that FDR failed the Jews or at least could have done more to save them from the Holocaust. Winik claims that FDR chose inaction time after time about stopping Hitler’s Final Solution. Winik thought that FDR could have rallied the country in his fire side chats and that he could have dealt with the anti-Semitism in his own cabinet. Winik does spend time discussing FDR’s health in 1944. Winik claims FDR missed his own “Emancipation Proclamation Moment” by not stopping the holocaust. Winik also provides a review of the history of World War II.
The story is interesting but in my opinion Winik has failed to make his case. I do agree the United States could have done more to save the Jews. We could have taken in more refugees, earlier but by 1944 it was too late. I think that FDR and Churchill decided that winning the War as fast as possible was the best approach and in 1944 they may have been correct. According to Winik the British government took the early claims about the concentration camp seriously whereas, he claims the U.S. government buried the reports.
Winik does discuss the “War Refugee Board” operated by the Treasury Department; it is credited with rescuing more than 200,000 Jews from the Holocaust. Winik uses the board’s success to show that FDR could have done more.
The book is well written and researched and Winik is a great storyteller. The book is an interesting read for those interested in the subject but it does not live up to its title. I picked up some great trivia information to add to my collection. Arthur Morey does a good job narrating the book. The book is fairly long at just over 21 hours.
6 of 7 people found this review helpful