Regular price: £24.19
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for £24.19
Would you ever listen to anything by Phillip Thomas Tucker again?
I doubt it.
What does Grover Gardner bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you just read the book?
The ability to "read the book" while working...I do like Grover Gardner as a narrator and have many books read by him.
If you could play editor, what scene or scenes would you have cut from Barksdale's Charge?
I would've cut a lot actually. First I'd point out that the author is contradicting himself in the main premise of the book as well as facts. An example of fact, he mentions the fact (multiple times) that the Mississippi brigade was defeated at Malvern Hill and also at Fredericksburg (during the Chancellorsville campaign), both previous to Gettysburg. However he says, also multiple times that the Mississippi brigade was undefeated when they got to Gettysburg.
Any additional comments?
The author did a great deal of research and I liked the detail and first hand accounts of the book, but I didn't like he writing style. His main theory is that the Mississippi brigades charge should be "the real high water mark." But when I finished the book I felt he actually disproved his theory. He says basically of Pickett's Charge that they did get to cemetery ridge, did break the union line, but couldn't maintain their position and had to withdraw. That's true, however he keeps mentioning how close Barksdale was to the ridge and if they got there the south would win a crushing victory at Gettysburg and win the war. However he doesn't seem to take into account, seriously if at all, that the brigade would basically be out of ammunition, without support, in the middle of the union lines with union reinforcements on the way. Had it gotten to the ridge, wouldn't it seem to be reasonable to assume that what happened to Armistead could happen to Barksdale? He seems to believe that the Mississippi Brigade stepping foot on Cemetery Ridge alone would win the war for the Confederacy. I just had a problem with that.
If you had family in the Mississippi brigade then this would be a definite book to read as you can maybe get some idea of exactly what your ancestor saw through the first hand accounts. If you're interested in Gettysburg, then you could get the book by Sears or, my personal favorite, Witness to Gettysburg. I would advise against this otherwise however. He contradicts himself too often and is very repetitive with points and phrases that had me wanting to delete it before finishing.
1 of 4 people found this review helpful