Regular price: £28.29
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for £28.29
From the title and description I expected a more of less comprehensive history of the Central Pacific campaign. In particular I expected at least an attempt to explain the planning and strategy of the campaign. Instead Cleaver is laser focused on the experiences of the air groups and the individual air crew. He has dug up a lot of good detail on the lives and missions of carrier aviators and those stories are informative and interesting. He does a decent job on the equipment, especially the Hellcat and Helldiver. Less so on the Avenger. The book also starts off strongly with a review of the development of American carriers and carrier doctrine in the pre-war period. It even does a good job of sketching even the events of the early war, setting the stage for August 1943
Unfortunately when the narrative reaches the start of the titular campaign the book's focus shifts to the micro level. Missions are described, the stories of individual pilots and air crew are told. Occasionally we get some strategic explanation, but never an over all clear picture.
Still glad I read it, with a title and description that match the content of the book I would rate it highly, just not the book it claims to be.
Tom Perkins does a fine job with the material and keeps the narrative moving forward. He does what most of the better narrators do, reads it well enough that you can enjoy the book and not think much about the narration.
3 of 3 people found this review helpful
This book deals with the minutiae of the naval war in the Pacific during the periods indicated in the title. The author does an excellent job in presenting what was essentially a carrier war with just enough background information not to bog his tale down. As with most of the recent histories, it is told from the perspective of the participants, rather than just the overall strategic picture. When dealing with the minutiae of the naval war in the Pacific, one ought to get a narrator who has a familiarity with both said Navy and the Pacific and how to pronounce the terminology and geography associated with them.
2 of 2 people found this review helpful