Regular price: £13.59
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for £13.59
It's not that the story of Communism in Hollywood is a boring one, it certainly isn't, but this particular take contains some of the dullest writing on the subject I've ever seen.
Acronyms abound, and instead of concentrating on the whys of notable incidents, including the Moscow Show Trials and their influence, and the reasoning behind them, I found myself constantly having to stop and research to discover the significance.
Perhaps this would be a good read for people who are already well-versed in Communism lore, but it definitely falls flat for a newbie to the subject.
It also doesn't help that the narrator fumbles and drawls his way through the already turgid narrative in a dreary, emotionless monotone.
I am assured that it gets better in the final third, but I'm afraid I shall never find out as, keen as I am to learn more on the subject, I have had to stop listening. I shall return this audiobook and try to find something with more vitality. I urge any prospective listeners to do the same.
Dalton Trumbo wrote that the HUAC committee and the actions of the Communist Party USA created only victims. The Radoshes have here a well researched well told history about a minor but significant period of US history.
Well read, a little slow getting started, Red Star Over Hollywood establishes the main characters, then follows them through the years to the present.
I think if one has a favorite or hero from the Blacklist period---read this. If anyone thinks they know who the villains were--read this.
If I have a criticism, it's the one I have about most books about this subject. For the studio artists and workers, some Communist and some not, none famous, who were in the 1945 Warner Brothers Strike, the blacklist never ended. They never worked in the movie business again.
Good book. Worth reading.
2 of 2 people found this review helpful
For those of us who love that spy-befouled time of post-World War II this is an interesting read. The audio book is divided into three parts with the first being the least interesting. The narrative gains momentum, however, and ultimately I was sorry to have the book end. I wish the authors had given lip service to the spy trials which were going on before and during the Hollywood investigations. Except for the slow startup, the authors do a worthwhile job and its worth the listen. Particularly good is the authors' new material by and about Dalton Trumbo. It's interesting to note that the Hollywood "blacklist" was an contrivance of the studios and not the government.
3 of 5 people found this review helpful