"Top 10 Science Fiction & Fantasy Books of 2008" (Kansas City Star)
Regular price: £20.09
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for £20.09
Customer ReviewsMost Helpful
By Gina A. Emory on 09-05-12
Excellent story AND narration
If you could sum up Marsbound in three words, what would they be?
I love Joe Haldeman. The Forever War is one of my favorite sci-fi books ever. I listened to Starbound first, not realizing it was part of a trilogy. After finishing it, I HAD to start at the beginning of the trilogy,so got Marsbound. It is another excellent Haldeman story!
What does Liza Kaplan bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you just read the book?
She does a really great job of bringing Carmen to life. She sounds just the way I figured she'd sound at the age she is in this book.
Any additional comments?
Get the entire trilogy. It's an excellent read!
3 of 3 people found this review helpful
By Wes Parker on 19-03-09
"Marsbound" initially impressed me as a better than average YA sci-fi story; Carmen seemed at first an interesting character to get to know, and the structure of the story recalled many of the Heinlein YA stories that I cut my teeth on, many years ago. Around the time that Carmen was getting acclimated to Mars and Solingen kept getting nastier, I started to chafe at the lack of pace and coherence. I eventually persevered to the end, but by the time I finished it was more of a chore than a pleasure.
Perhaps had I read this book instead of listening to it, I'd have enjoyed it more. Kaplan's narration was just bad. I know I've been spoiled by narrators such as John Lee and the late, lamented Patrick Tull, but I had expected someone who is, after all, a voice actress to do a better job. Her "voice" for Carmen and the overall narration sounded like a child in elementary school reading a book in a sing-song (truly jarring when she was narrating a sex scene) and her voices for other females reminded me more of some anime characters I've heard. Really, really bad anime characters.
I don't recommend this book. For good YA titles, try John Marsden's "Tomorrow" series, or the YA books by Charles de Lint. For good YA sci-fi, Heinlein is dated, but still good. John Scalzi's "Zoe's Tale" is great. Take the money you would have spent on this book, and look for one of those instead.
4 of 5 people found this review helpful