Regular price: £23.49
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for £23.49
Any additional comments?
I didn't know anything about this crime or the convictions. The title indicates there was an injustice but that's about it. So I was disappointed the audio starts with a prologue which pretty much summarises the entire book. I strongly recommend you skip this.
The rest of the book covers in great detail, the community of the time, the horrific crime, search for a suspect, conviction and aftermath. There are a lot of characters and I found it tricky to keep track of who was who. Because it's told chronologically there's also the introduction of new characters throughout, sometimes just to make a point and then they disappear.
I realise there's a duty with non fiction to tell the story from many viewpoints and angles, but this just led to the feeling I was looking down at the scene and not involved. I therefore didn't feel any emotional attachment to the victim or the suspects, and didn't much care what happened (compounded by the prologue having already given away the ending).
So, is this book worth it? Yes I think so. The crime took place within my lifetime in the 1980s and I found it scary to hear how the investigation was handled. I remember when DNA testing was first used in a case in the UK and found it fascinating to hear how this new technology became incorporated into the judicial process of this case. It was also narrated well. This is the second book I've listened to by Kevin and I find he keeps a calm, steady pace with even tone, just right for such a serious non-fiction topic. Overall rating 3.5 stars.
Finally I must mention two things 1) I received a non-cost copy of this book in exchange for a review. 2) I can only read gifted books on the US site but I'm an avid reader and all my reviews (over 70 to date) can be found on the UK site.
8 of 8 people found this review helpful
Wow, such a difficult book to listen to because of the stories of those involved in the case. The writing and narration are outstanding but the story is truly heart breaking.
How can 6 people be wrongly convicted for a murder they did not commit? How can they be put to trial and imprisoned and spend years behind bars while innocent? How can they be released then have to fight for compensation for the time they were wrongfully imprisoned? If you were in their shoes would you "confess" or would you maintain your innocence?
This is a sign of a good book - made me think and question. Amazing listening!
7 of 7 people found this review helpful