Narrator not suited to the book

The narrator would be more suited to the likes of Little Women than this. She is far to prim for narrating Paks' character

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

love this series of books

I have the hardback books but due to sight problems I decided to try the audio books and I'm glad I did! They are great and I could listen to the narrator all day! A must for fans of the books

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

Disappointing

Audiobook read by Jennifer van Dyck.
I'd read good things about this series, so I really wanted to like it, but on balance I didn't like it as much as I thought I would. Paksenarrion runs away from home to join a mercenary army rather than marry a local farmer. This book is the account of her first three years as she learns her trade in an army run by Duke Phelan. There's a LOT of detail about the minutiae of like in the military. (And I mean a LOT.) Paks flourishes. The training is good. The Duke looks after his soldiers, and Paks learns her trade well. She's gradually given small promotions and becomes one of the Duke's trusted minions. The good thing about this is the detailed and immersive worldbuilding, though it's in a generic medievaloid setting. The description is excellent, but, as a minion in the Duke's mercenary force, Paks doesn't have much agency, Sure, though naive at first, she learns her trade, is doggedly loyal, gains some loot, and always does her best, but... (You knew there would be a but, didn't you.) This is lacking in story. Paks doesn't really have much of an arc, though there are hints of one to come. She doesn't have much of an emotional journey either. Things happen to Paks, then other things happen, and then more things happen. The army marches here, the army marches there, Paks takes part in (well written) battles, and in sieges. She loses comrades, and saves comrades. I understand that the trilogy (The Deed of Paksenarrion) was written as one massive book and split into three, so this (long as it is) is mostly set-up. There's an incident at the beginning which I expected to pay off at the end, but it doesn't. (I don't know whether it will in subsequent books.) The narrator's occasional attempts at accents doesn't work particularly well for me. Because of her American accent , Paks often sounds like Pox, which is a bit unfortunate.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Not as good as reading the book

I love the books of this series, so was slightly disappointed to find the audio a little samey. The narrator has a good voice, but I found it hard to tell the difference between the characters. This wasn't helped by the author seeming to reuse several names an awful lot.

Having said that, it's a rip-roaring high fantasy adventure, and not at all run of the mill. You get magic and Knights in shining armour, but only from a distance as Paks, former shepherd, runs away to join a mercenary company.

The author's own military background gives the story depth and detail, the misery of campaign as well as the solidity of bonds formed is brought across strongly. It's interesting to consider the hardships faced by a mercenary company operating under essentially medieval conditions.

The heroine is occasionally a bit TOO perfect, and remains resolutely stubborn and naive right through to the end, but it is a solidly entertaining story nonetheless.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Good,

I enjoyed this book and I am looking forward to the next installment of this series.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Good story, bad narration

Wish I’d read this as a paper book or narrated by someone else. The narration was so monotone that it was hard to follow and lost all narrative pacing. A description of a landscape, thick of battle, intimate moment, or even rape was all delivered exactly the same. Super disappointing. I was listening to it while crocheting so it was fine for it to just be noise in the background but want to read the actual book so I know what the story is supposed to be like.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

one of the best

surely one of the very best fantasy novels ever written and just the beginning of a wonderful series.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Grate book

Grate book and the narration was good I'm looking forward to the next book

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Outstanding

Loved this story, couldn’t stop listening, read it in a day, great details, enjoyed the characters, easy to listen to narration. Thank you

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

great story with an awful narrator

great story with an awful narrator, the narrator injected a number of awful accents thus spoiling the enjoyment.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

4 people found this helpful