Regular price: £10.89
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for £10.89
Lots of enjoyable space adventure silliness with a lashings of British humour; dead-pan, underplayed and very funny. Set in an indefinable era that is a clash of cultures; psuedo-Victorian and 21st Century, it's almost a game of spot the film reference.
The reading by Clive Catterall was soft and gentle, which generally suited the style of the book. However, sometimes I felt the reading was a little too soft, as thought he was reading someone a bedtime story and hoping they would drop off shortly.
Would you try another book written by Toby Frost or narrated by Clive Catterall?
I read the whole Toby Frost series a few years ago and love the old fashioned Boys Own comic style of writing, applied to a space opera. The written voice of Capt. Smith was that of a 19th century adventurer, typical of those who built the British Empire.
However, the performance in the audio is flat, dull and insufficiently different for clear identification of the characters. It has turned a witty yarn into a yawn.
Would you recommend Space Captain Smith to your friends? Why or why not?
No. Go read the books.
Who might you have cast as narrator instead of Clive Catterall?
The late Rick Mayall would have been wonderfull.
Would you listen to Space Captain Smith again? Why?
Yes. Its a light, fun, entertaining book filled with and abundant of humorous pop culture references.
What was one of the most memorable moments of Space Captain Smith?
I found all of the characters to be instantly likable.
What about Clive Catterall’s performance did you like?
I thought his understated delivery fit perfectly with the pace and style of the story.
Did you have an extreme reaction to this book? Did it make you laugh or cry?
Several times in this book I found myself laughing out loud.
Any additional comments?
I hesitated about buying this book because of the bad reviews on Audible, but I finally downloaded because of recommendation I've found on other sites. I am so glad I did, all three books in the trilogy are a delight to listen to. It's a lighthearted adventure that sucks in within the first few minutes. If you are a fan of Terry Pratchett and fun sci-fi adventures, I highly recommend this book and the rest in the trilogy.
2 of 2 people found this review helpful
My neighbors must wonder why I am snickering as I do yard work. This is the book that kept me smiling as I pulled weeds in 100+ weather.
This is the kind of space opera I like: quirky, sly, tongue-in-cheek, 'don't take yourself too seriously'. Our hero, Smith, is a little ego heavy; clueless, but well-meaning. He has an alien sidekick, and android female pilot. The potential girlfriend is a flower child! (Google the term if you are too young to know what that refers to ;) .) Characters lean toward stereotypes, some from old war movies, but everybody has a back story and the sly humor makes them likable, each in their own way. Even the villains are entertaining.
The characters and plot are loosely patterned after Saturday afternoon serials from the movie houses of yesteryear, with lots of references to 'pop culture' (i.e. movies; don't miss Casablanca). But don't worry if you don't catch them all, I'm sure I didn't. The story is written in the naive style of the '40's. However the book's voice is subtly self-aware. The humor comes from playing with underhanded, sneaky exaggeration of the stereotypes. Many sacred cows are slaughtered.
The narration is very good. I could only fault it slightly for being delivered in soto voice. But that is a quibble. The narrator does know how to deliver this kind of humor. (Some do not.)
To achieve humor and sustain it for a whole novel, I think, is an under-appreciated skill. The humor is subtle. That is, the reader has pay attention to detail. For instance our hero, Smith, while infatuated with the potential love interest, totally misses the signals that she tries to send indicating her interest. The author was able convey that nuance in a warm, human tone, without demeaning either of them.
I've read all three audiobooks, now, and can say the author didn't let me down. I would put it in the same category as "Starship Grifters" by Robert Kroese, "Willful Child" by Steven Erikson, and "Emperor Mollusk vs the Sinister Brain" by A Lee Martinez.
1 of 3 people found this review helpful