The Guns of the South
- Narrated by: Paul Costanzo
- Length: 24 hrs and 50 mins
- Unabridged Audiobook
- Release date: 11-10-16
- Language: English
- Publisher: Tantor Audio
Regular price: £39.39
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for £39.39
Customer ReviewsMost Helpful
By Steve Hocking on 31-03-18
This story has at its heart and interesting idea but ultimately is over long and over indulgent. The pace is slow but evokes the time and place well.
I enjoyed the story but ultimately it felt like a labour more that anything else.
By Steve Downing on 30-09-17
Guns of the South
The title and cover of this book tells you exactly 'what-if' scenario you're getting. Harry Turtledove clearly put a lot of research into this book. The level of detail is high and informs the greater narrative the story follows. Some of the characters we follow are historical heavy-hitters and it's fascinating to follow this speculation on how they might have reacted to the balance of the American Civil War falling in favour decisively for the Confederacy.
I've heard better narrators; I've heard worse. This one interprets - what I suspect are - commas in the text too heavily, so that some sentences are read in a peculiarly stop-start style. Also the narrator's sole voicing for the characters in the book strays dangerously close to Elmer Fudd.
Still, a competent reading of a very interesting idea. Worth a punt.
Customer ReviewsMost Helpful
By Tami A. on 28-10-16
Loved the book but...
This has been a favourite of mine since I bought my first copy in 1992. I love the storyline and how the author works out the plot lines. I also love how Lee deals with the oddity of time travel with the greatest of ease. It might've been interesting to see how he would've marveled at the modern world had he had the chance to see it.
I did NOT care much for the performance. While he did make effort to have the characters speak with the proper enthusiasm, he mispronounced simple words, all the characters sounded the same, and the reading of the story outside of the characters speaking was very dull and monotonous. Many times during long spells of just story, I found myself nodding off. I would not recommend this for listening to while driving.
I WOULD listen to it again, as it's a favourite of mine but please let me know if you ever get someone who knows how to read and make a book come alive for the listener to perform this title.
25 of 26 people found this review helpful
By Chris on 11-07-17
The narrator was good, his southern accents were convincing, albeit his Afrikaner accents not so much (in fairness that's a tough accent for most).
I liked the storyline but couldn't understand why the AWB didn't just travel to the Transvaal. The South African Republic existed at the time, and they would've made more logical allies. Anyway a good and enthralling story nonetheless.
2 of 2 people found this review helpful