Good for a brief study of the Prophet's life

I appreciated the conciseness of the book as I needed a quick read/ listen of the Prophet's biography. But I wish the narrator didn't over-do the Arabic pronunciations. In some cases she sounded like she was about to dislocate her jaw in trying to pronounce some very simple words like "Khadija". I wish she had stuck to the anglicised pronunciations of the Arabic words because it was extremely cringy otherwise. Some words she pronounced entirely wrong in her unnecessary efforts and though being a Muslim myself I still could not decipher what exactly she was reading about.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

The life of the greatest person in history..

A sublime human being and the greatest prophet. Conquered Mecca through humility, kindness and reconciliation.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

So near and yet so far;)

I’ve read this book a couple of times but years ago.

The intro is intriguing Rogerson explains why he is not a Muslim, in a charming but unconvincing way. He says his best Muslim friends are bad muslims who drink and chase women, yet have faith and can fast Ramadan with the pious. I love those guys too.

I think the real reason shows itself in the pages of the book. Brother Barnaby, in his intro says he loves a good story, but he doesn’t believe in the full story. He says Muhammed didn’t want to spread Islam beyond Arabia, but tells us of his letters to the rulers of Byzantium Iran and Ethiopia, come on. He tells how Muhammed stayed faithful to one woman 15 years his senior for twenty five years yet was polygamous after her death. He pointed out that Muhammed owned a slave, who was so beaten down, when his family claimed him he chose Muhammed above his family.

He did this for love and even though Brother Barnaby knows this he can’t throw off his Anglican upbringing. Brother Barnaby’s account of the Prophets death moved me to tears, and you can’t write like that without sharing the love. Don’t worry Brother Barnaby your friends are safe, Allah says if all men were pure and free from sin he would sweep them away and populate the world with sinners so could forgive, because He loves to forgive. Thank you Brother B

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Does not capture the essence of Muhammad

- The book starts well by adopting a neutral perspective on the story of Muhammad
- It narrates the facts without giving a holistic overview of the historical context
- Muhammad is depicted as an evil and violent person
- The consequences of the acts that might seem negative were not highlighted
- Muhammad's life had a positive impact on humanity. The impact wasn't highlighted properly.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Poison within the honey

The author appears to be admiring the prophet, but portrays him as a person who would support his followers even if they are wrong. A man who chases after his love for women, to the point of a controversial revelation to get him to marry a woman already married to his previously adopted son.
The author describes prophet Mohamed peace be upon him as picking a fight with the jews in Madina, because he didn't like their presence. And skips the betrayal of the jews to the muslims in war and their attempts to assassinate the prophet to show the brutality of an undeserved punishment.
The description of how the Quran was revealed to the prophet is made to convey doubt within the wording of the Quran.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

7 people found this helpful

Extremely poor

Writer hasn’t portrayed the real person at all. Wrong and disrespectful use of vocab is used to describe Prophet Peace Be Upon Him. The book is a complete betrayal as the writer tries to give positive side and at the same time portrays a complete wrong image of him

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful